530 Main Street, Cromwell, CT, 06457

Nostalgia Cromwell

There's a New Taste in Town

Cromwell’s newest Sports bar with an Italian twist

We're more than just pizza!

Visit us Today

Monday : Closed
Tuesday – Saturday : 11am – 12am
Sunday : 12pm – 11pm

(860) 404-9550
530 Main Street, Cromwell, CT 

Wanna eat something ?

The Menu

In a Hurry?


If you’re someone who’s always on the go, Nostalgia has got you covered with our daily Grab-n-Go options. You no longer have to compromise on the quality of your meal just because you don’t have enough time to sit down and eat. Our team of culinary experts meticulously prepare these meals, ensuring that you get a delicious and satisfying meal that’s ready to go when you are. These options are available in-store at our front store and are perfect for busy individuals who need to make the most out of their day. Plus, you can always rely on Nostalgia to deliver fresh and tasty options that’ll keep you coming back for more. So, the next time you’re in a hurry, swing by our store to grab a quick, hassle-free meal that’ll give you the energy you need to tackle the day ahead.

About Us

A Cromwell Story

Michele York and her business partner, Brian Bonneau, are the owners of Nostalgia, a sports bar dining a 30-foot bar, and dining area to accommodate 60 people. 

Many area residents will be familiar with the pair, who grew up in Cromwell and graduated Cromwell High School  in 1990. Bonneau owned a bar in town, called the Well, for 15 years. Bonneau closed that business to open Nostalgia with York.

York was the chef for over 20 years at Zerios, an Italian restaurant and deli, and she was a partner in Rustic Pizza in Middletown. 

The restaurant has a capacity to seat 60 people, and, in addition to pizza, will offer grinders, Italian dishes, burgers, wraps, appetizers, salads and specials.

Our Food

Thanks to You

Our Reviews

My husband and I ordered pizza last night and I have to say that it was awesome. It was the best that we have had in some time. We definitely will be coming back soon. great job!

Donna Janik

Decided to try something new and it didn’t disappoint! Pizza and service were great

Kristine Lynn

Stopped in on the first night they opened. It was busy, but my food came out really fast. Pizza, boneless wings, salad and garlic bread were all excellent, and my picky eater of a son loved it, too! Cannot wait to see the place develop over the next month or so and come back for a sit down experience!

Katie Meredith

We tried Nostalgia for the first time the other night. Dinner was excellent and the desserts were too. Everyone was very friendly. We will definitely be going back.

Felicia Harris Robichaud